# Proposal Overview
![image](https://i.ibb.co/X5RVw5p/w3reg.png)

Currently, there is no automated registrar available for judgements on the Kusama People parachain. To enable the People chain to launch on Polkadot and migrate identities from the Hermit relay, we propose developing the necessary steps on the W3F registrar backend and making it open-source for all registrars. We are seeking funding to continue the development and maintenance of these open-source registrar tools, which are essential for the ecosystem. This includes reworking the existing tools, `polkadot-registrar-watcher` and `polkadot-registrar-challenger`, to integrate with the Polkadot-People parachain for judgements and identities. 

Additionally, we propose building a pathway to enable a much broader adoption of media verification through the bridge-manager to matrix. This will allow verification of wide variety of social medias with minimal maintenance burden. To note out that social media verification will enable [601 - Agents Program](https://polkadot.polkassembly.io/referenda/601) to measure done PoW in social media back to SS58 accounts/onchain identities.

## Key Objectives

1. **Maintain and Enhance polkadot-registrar-watcher:**
    - Ensure compatibility with the upcoming Polkadot People's system parachain.
    - Rework watcher to use [subxt](https://github.com/paritytech/subxt) for improved maintainability and long-term support.

2. **Maintain and Enhance polkadot-registrar-challenger:**
    - Fork and enhance the repository for broader usability (forkable backend for all registrars).
    - Integrate Beeper/Bridge-Manager for Puppeteer bridging of Twitter/Discord/Email DM verifications into Matrix (avoiding the expensive Twitter API). This will allow future verification of Telegram, 

## Funding Request

We propose hiring one full-stack developer, Dan, and one part-time developer, Tommi. The project requires:

**1.5 Full-Time Equivalents (FTE) for a period of 4 weeks:**
  - **Tommi:** Over 10 years of experience.
  - **Dan:** Over 20 years of experience.
  - **Estimated rate:** $80 per hour.
  - **Total budget:** $19,200 (1.5 FTE * 4 weeks * 40 hours per week * $80 per hour).

Based on the DOT rate of 7.223 as of 2024-05-27, the final amount in DOT considering a 3% slippage/conversion is calculated as follows:

**Slippage/Conversion 3%**: $19200 * 0.03 = $576  
**Final Payment USD**: $19200 + $576 = $19776  
**Final Amount in DOT**: $19776 / 7.223 ≈ 2737.92 DOT  

## Milestones

This proposal seeks funding for the initial milestone, focusing on creating a Minimum Viable Product (MVP). Totaling 240 development hours:

**Milestone 1: Transition to people-chain and twitter Integration over matrix (240 hours)**

| Task | Estimated Hours | Description |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Initial Setup and Environment Preparation | 30 hours | Fork and clone the `polkadot-registrar-watcher` and `polkadot-registrar-challenger` repositories. Set up development environments and necessary dependencies for `polkadot-api` or `subxt`. Set up `bridge-manager` to receive DMs in a secure fashion over an end-to-end encrypted bridge. |
| Enhance `polkadot-registrar-watcher` | 70 hours | Integrate the watcher with the Kusama-People system parachain. Choose between `polkadot-api` and `subxt` for subscribing to the people chain state. Implement basic functionality to monitor judgements and identities. Test and verify the watcher's compatibility and functionality. |
| Enhance `polkadot-registrar-challenger` | 80 hours | Integrate Beeper/Bridge-Manager to be used in verification. Test and verify the challenger's basic functionality. |
| Create Reference UI Implementation | 40 hours | Develop a basic registrar UI in `SolidJS` for new identity creation and automated verification with challenges. |
| Documentation and Initial Testing | 20 hours | Write initial documentation for the tools. Conduct basic testing and gather feedback for improvements.  Add support for nicknames. |

**Milestone 2: Expansion of adapters (340 hours)**

| Task                           | Estimated Hours | Description |
|--------------------------------|-----------------|-------------|
| DNS TXT Checker Implementation | 40 hours        | Implement a DNS TXT checker for automated web field verification. |
| Discord Challenge Verification | 20 hours        | Implement Discord challenge verification through Bridge-Manager. |
| Custom Field Implementation    | 140 hours       | Implement custom field verification for Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, Signal, LinkedIn, Slack, and Telegram challenges through Bridge-Manager. |
| PGP Fingerprint Verification   | 60 hours        | Integrate PGP fingerprint verification using the `rpgp` Rust library. |
| Frontend Implementation        | 80 hours        | Enhance the frontend UI to support the new challenge methods and ensure a seamless user experience. |

**Possible future 3. milestone**
| Task                           | Estimated Hours | Description |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Reddit verifications  | 40 hours        | Custom Field verification for Reddit creating adapter for their DM API |
|  "Registrar for Registrars"  | 60 hours        |  Develop an easy-to-use form for submitting registrar applications to OpenGov, simplifying the current complex process. will allows easy submission to create a governance proposal to register new registrar on Polkadot without knowledge of XCM/weights/people-pallet extrinsics/etc. |


## Cost Savings through Puppeteering with Beeper/Bridge-Manager

One of the significant advantages of our approach is the integration of Beeper/Bridge-Manager to handle direct message verifications via Matrix. By using Puppeteer to bridge Twitter, Discord, and Email DMs into Matrix, we decrease the maintenance scope and can avoid the extremely costly Twitter API v2, which can run up to $5,000 per month. This puppeteering method allows us to automate DM verifications without incurring such high costs, making our solution more sustainable and cost-effective for the community. Additionally bridge-manager allows us to add verification of Instagram, Facebook, WhatsApp, Telegram, LinkedIn etc. through direct messages. 

## Support and Licensing

While the code will be released under the MIT 2.0 license, we do not provide free support. For those registrars requiring assistance, we offer consultation services at paid rate. This ensures that our team can focus on continuous improvement and maintenance while providing professional support as needed.

## Background

The `polkadot-registrar-challenger` and `polkadot-registrar-watcher` projects were initially developed by the Web3 Foundation as an automated registrar service for Polkadot on-chain identities. However, this project has been decommissioned and is no longer updated, leaving the ecosystem without a functional automated registrar. This has held back the release of the Kusama-People chain on Polkadot. Our proposal aims to revive and enhance this service to support the broader adoption and usability of on-chain identity verification.

## Why Rotko Networks([AS142108](https://www.peeringdb.com/net/36301))?

We are heavily invested in the success of the People’s chain. One of the main motivations for us becoming a SEA infra provider was the shared vision of delivering a global low latency public DNS service that supports resolving names issued at Polkadot. We believe that with careful design, the identity pallet and People’s chain has the potential to become the internet native naming service to manage gTLD domains. Additionally we have already obtained ipv4/24 and ipv6/48 ranges for upcoming anycast service to provide global routing for web3 needs. 

## Team and Experience

 **[Tommi](https://matrix.to/#/@hitchhooker:matrix.org):**

  - Ecosystem validator for around ~4 years.
  - Full-stack developer with over 10 years of experience.
  - IBP infra builder for South East Asia at [Rotko Networks](https://rotko.net/docs/introduction.html).
  - devops/programming @ Rome Blockchain Labs: [benqi](https://benqi.fi), [moonwell](https://moonwell.fi), [sceptre](https://www.sceptre.fi/), etc.. 
  - GitHub: [hitchhooker](https://github.com/hitchhooker)

 **[Dan](https://matrix.to/#/@meeb:matrix.org):**
  - Over 20 years of programming experience.
  - Expertise in Rust and functional programming.
  - Passion for demoscene music & writing drum machines.
  - GitHub: [d-r](https://github.com/d-r)

**Team Code Repositories**

- [Unlabored - Proxmox Ansible infrastructure for blockchains](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/unlabored)
- [snitch - Prometheus watchdog alerts to Pushover](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/snitch)
- [genpeerid - Generate peerid from secret_ed25519](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/genpeerid)
- [bootnode/endpoint monitoring](https://github.com/ibp-network/config/tree/main/scripts)
- [wenbeefy dashboard](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/treasury/396)
- [polka.run - polkavm disassembler GUI(MVP/discontinued until upstream stable)](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/polka.run)
- polkavm example game-of-life([host](https://github.com/hitchhooker/polkavm/tree/game-of-life/examples)/[guest](https://github.com/hitchhooker/polkavm/blob/game-of-life/guest-programs/example-game-of-life/src/main.rs))

## Work Repositories for proposal

- [w3reg.org - SolidJS reference UI](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/w3reg.org)
- [polkadot-registrar-watcher](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/polkadot-registrar-watcher)
- [polkadot-registrar-challenger](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/polkadot-registrar-challenger)
- [bridge-manager](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/bridge-manager)

Thank you for considering our proposal.

# Proposal Overview

Currently, there is no registrar available for automated judgements on Kusama. To address this gap and provide a wider range of registrars, we seek funding to continue the development and maintenance of open-source registrar tools that are crucial for the ecosystem. This includes reworking existing tools, `polkadot-registrar-watcher` and `polkadot-registrar-challenger`, to integrate with the Kusama-People system parachain for judgements and identities.

## Key Objectives

1. **Maintain and Enhance polkadot-registrar-watcher:**
    - Ensure compatibility with the Kusama-People system parachain.
    - Utilize either the [polkadot-api](https://github.com/polkadot-js/api) or [subxt](https://github.com/paritytech/subxt) for long-term supported functionality.

2. **Maintain and Enhance polkadot-registrar-challenger:**
    - Fork and enhance the repository for broader usability (forkable backend for all registrars).
    - Integrate Beeper/Bridge-Manager for Puppeteer bridging of Twitter/Discord/Email DM verifications into Matrix (avoiding the expensive Twitter API).

## Funding Request

We propose hiring one full-stack developer, Dan, and one part-time developer, Tommi. The project requires:

**1.5 Full-Time Equivalents (FTE) for a period of 4 weeks:**
  - **Tommi:** Over 10 years of experience.
  - **Dan:** Over 20 years of experience.
  - Estimated rate: $80 per hour.
  - Total budget: $19,200 (1.5 FTE * 4 weeks * 40 hours per week * $80 per hour).

Based on the DOT rate of 7.223 as of 2024-05-27, the final amount in DOT considering a 3% slippage/conversion is calculated as follows:

**Slippage/Conversion 3%**: $19200 * 0.03 = $576  
**Final Payment USD**: $19200 + $576 = $19776  
**Final Amount in DOT**: $19776 / 7.223 ≈ 2737.92 DOT  

## Milestones

This proposal seeks funding for the initial milestone, focusing on creating a Minimum Viable Product (MVP). Totaling 240 development hours:

**Milestone 1: Development and Integration (MVP) (240 hours)**

| Task | Estimated Hours | Description |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Initial Setup and Environment Preparation | 30 hours | Fork and clone the `polkadot-registrar-watcher` and `polkadot-registrar-challenger` repositories. Set up development environments and necessary dependencies for `polkadot-api` or `subxt`. Set up `bridge-manager` to receive DMs in a secure fashion over an end-to-end encrypted bridge. |
| Enhance `polkadot-registrar-watcher` | 70 hours | Integrate the watcher with the Kusama-People system parachain. Choose between `polkadot-api` and `subxt` for subscribing to the people chain state. Implement basic functionality to monitor judgements and identities. Test and verify the watcher's compatibility and functionality. |
| Enhance `polkadot-registrar-challenger` | 80 hours | Integrate Beeper/Bridge-Manager to be used in verification. Test and verify the challenger's basic functionality. |
| Create Reference UI Implementation | 40 hours | Develop a basic registrar UI in `SolidJS` for new identity creation and automated verification with challenges. |
| Documentation and Initial Testing | 20 hours | Write initial documentation for the tools. Conduct basic testing and gather feedback for improvements. |

**Future work:**

**Governance Proposal for New Registrar Registration:**   
    - Prepare and propose a governance proposal to register as a new registrar on Kusama.  
    - Craft a governance vote that initiates the `addRegistrar` function with root origin on the system parachain.  
    - Provide the code and methods for this process as well-documented open-source resources for other registrars.  

**Additional Enhancements:**  
    - Implement a DNS TXT checker for automated web field verification (Code for the DNS checker was written a year ago and can be found [here](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/dns-txt-checker)).  
    - Implement Discord challenge verification through Matrix.   

## Cost Savings through Puppeteering with Beeper/Bridge-Manager

One of the significant advantages of our approach is the integration of Beeper/Bridge-Manager to handle direct message verifications via Matrix. By using Puppeteer to bridge Twitter, Discord, and Email DMs into Matrix, we decrease the maintenance scope and can avoid the extremely costly Twitter API v2, which can run up to $5,000 per month. This puppeteering method allows us to automate DM verifications without incurring such high costs, making our solution more sustainable and cost-effective for the community.

## Support and Licensing

While the code will be released under the MIT 2.0 license, we do not provide free support. For those registrars requiring assistance, we offer consultation services at paid rate. This ensures that our team can focus on continuous improvement and maintenance while providing professional support as needed.

## Background

The `polkadot-registrar-challenger` and `polkadot-registrar-watcher` projects were initially developed by the Web3 Foundation as an automated registrar service for Polkadot on-chain identities. However, this project has been decommissioned and is no longer updated, leaving the ecosystem without a functional automated registrar. This has held back the release of the Kusama-People chain on Polkadot. Our proposal aims to revive and enhance this service to support the broader adoption and usability of on-chain identity verification.

## Why [Rotko Networks](https://rotko.net/docs/team.html)(AS142108)?

We are heavily invested in the success of the People’s chain. One of the main motivations for us becoming a SEA infra provider was the shared vision of delivering a global low latency public DNS service that supports resolving web3 domains in applications like browsers. We believe that with careful design, the identity pallet and People’s chain have the potential to challenge ICANN as the single truth issuer of top-level domains (.com, .net, .io, .network). It’s been nearly 15 years since the launch of Namecoin, yet we still do not have a single global low latency public DNS supporting decentralized domain names. It’s time to change that.

## Team and Experience

 **[Tommi](https://matrix.to/#/@hitchhooker:matrix.org):**

  - Ecosystem validator for around ~4 years.
  - Full-stack developer with over 10 years of experience.
  - IBP infra builder for South East Asia at [Rotko Networks](https://rotko.net/docs/introduction.html).
  - Rome Blockchain Labs products: [benqi](benqi.fi), [moonwell](moonwell.fi), etc.. 
  - GitHub: [hitchhooker](https://github.com/hitchhooker)

 **[Dan](https://matrix.to/#/@meeb:matrix.org):**
  - Over 20 years of programming experience.
  - Expertise in Rust and functional programming.
  - Passion for demoscene music & writing drum machines.
  - GitHub: [d-r](https://github.com/d-r)

**Team Code Repositories**

- [Unlabored - Proxmox Ansible infrastructure for blockchains](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/unlabored)
- [snitch - Prometheus watchdog alerts to Pushover](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/snitch)
- [genpeerid - Generate peerid from secret_ed25519](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/genpeerid)
- [bootnode/endpoint monitoring](https://github.com/ibp-network/config/tree/main/scripts)
- [wenbeefy dashboard](https://kusama.polkassembly.io/treasury/396)
- [polka.run - polkavm disassembler GUI(MVP/discontinued until upstream stable)](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/polka.run)
- polkavm example game-of-life([host](https://github.com/hitchhooker/polkavm/tree/game-of-life/examples)/[guest](https://github.com/hitchhooker/polkavm/blob/game-of-life/guest-programs/example-game-of-life/src/main.rs))

## Work Repositories for proposal

- [w3reg.org - SolidJS reference UI](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/w3reg.org)
- [polkadot-registrar-watcher](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/polkadot-registrar-watcher)
- [polkadot-registrar-challenger](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/polkadot-registrar-challenger)
- [bridge-manager](https://github.com/rotkonetworks/bridge-manager)

Thank you for considering our proposal.

Proposal for Funding Open-Source Registrar Development Continuity

Treasury

- **Problem Statement:** Lack of an automated registrar for judgements on the Kusama People parachain, hindering its launch on Polkadot.
- **Significance:** Reviving and enhancing the registrar tools is crucial for ecosystem development and migration of identities.
- **Proposed Solution:** Develop and maintain open-source registrar tools, integrate with the Polkadot-People parachain, and automate media verification through Beeper/Bridge-Manager.
- **Expected Outcomes:** Enable broader adoption of media verification, decrease maintenance costs, and support the release of the Kusama-People chain on Polkadot.

#809 Open-Source Registrar Development Continuity